
Introduction
When studying limits, we often encounter expressions in which the denominator approaches zero. One particularly interesting example is:
At first glance, we might think that the expression simply becomes infinity because the numerator approaches 1 while the denominator approaches zero.
However, there is a deeper geometric explanation.
The most interesting aspect is that the expression behaves differently depending on whether the angle approaches zero from above or below the horizontal axis.
By using the unit circle, we can understand:
- Why cosine approaches 1 from both sides.
- Why the denominator changes its sign.
- Why the quotient becomes positive infinity on one side and negative infinity on the other.
- Why the two-sided limit does not exist.
Let’s derive this geometrically.
- Begin with the unit circle
Consider a unit circle with its centre at the origin.
The radius of the circle is 1.
A point on the circumference corresponding to an angle x (measured in radians) has coordinates:
Therefore, the horizontal coordinate is cos x and the vertical coordinate is sin x.
This gives us an important geometric interpretation of cosine: it represents the horizontal projection of the radius onto the horizontal axis.
As the angle approaches zero, the point on the circumference approaches the rightmost point of the circle.
Consequently:
Notice that cosine approaches positive 1 from both directions.
This is important because the numerator does not change its sign near zero.
- What happens when the angle approaches zero from above?
Imagine a point moving along the upper part of the unit circle towards the positive horizontal axis.
The angle is positive because it is measured anticlockwise from the positive horizontal axis.
The point lies in the first quadrant.
As the point approaches the horizontal axis:
- Its horizontal coordinate approaches 1.
- Its vertical coordinate approaches 0.
- Its angle approaches zero through positive values.
Therefore, both the numerator and denominator are positive.
Consider the expression .
As x approaches zero from the positive side, a positive number divided by a positive number gives a positive result.
But there is something more interesting.
The numerator approaches 1, while the denominator becomes increasingly small.
For example:
Angle 0.1 radians: cos x = 0.9950, cos x / x = 9.950
Angle 0.01 radians: cos x = 0.99995, cos x / x = 99.995
Angle 0.001 radians: cos x = 0.9999995, cos x / x = 999.9995
As the angle becomes smaller, the quotient becomes increasingly large.
Thus:
- What happens when the angle approaches zero from below?
Now imagine the point moving along the lower part of the unit circle towards the same positive horizontal axis.
This time, the point lies in the fourth quadrant.
The angle is negative because it is measured clockwise from the positive horizontal axis.
As the point approaches the horizontal axis:
- Its horizontal coordinate still approaches 1.
- Its vertical coordinate approaches 0.
- Its angle approaches zero through negative values.
Here is the important difference:
The cosine remains positive, but the angle is negative.
Therefore, a positive number divided by a negative number gives a negative result.
Consider the following values:
Angle -0.1 radians: cos x = 0.9950, cos x / x = -9.950
Angle -0.01 radians: cos x = 0.99995, cos x / x = -99.995
Angle -0.001 radians: cos x = 0.9999995, cos x / x = -999.9995
As the angle approaches zero from below, the quotient becomes increasingly negative.
Thus:
- The geometric reason: Why does the sign change?
Now let’s bring both situations together.
The upper and lower portions of the unit circle give us two different signed angles.
However, their horizontal projections remain positive.
This is the crucial observation.
First quadrant (above the axis): cosine is positive, the angle is positive, so the quotient is positive.
Fourth quadrant (below the axis): cosine is positive, the angle is negative, so the quotient is negative.
The point approaches the same location on the unit circle from two different directions.
Its horizontal coordinate approaches 1 in both cases.
But the signed angle changes from positive to negative.
Therefore, the sign change in the quotient comes from the denominator, not the numerator.
This is why the expression behaves differently on the two sides of zero.
- Why does the two-sided limit not exist?
For a two-sided limit to exist as a finite real number, the left-hand and right-hand limits must approach the same value.
In our example:
But:
The two sides do not approach the same value.
Consequently, the limit of as
does not exist.
It is also important to distinguish between two mathematical statements.
First: The function is undefined at zero.
When x equals zero:
Division by zero is undefined.
Second: The two-sided limit does not exist.
Even though we can examine the function at values arbitrarily close to zero, its behaviour from the two directions is different.
These are related but distinct reasons.
- An additional geometric insight: Why radians matter
There is another interesting connection between this expression and the geometry of the unit circle.
For a circle of radius r, the arc length is:
On the unit circle, the radius is 1.
Therefore:
This means that the angle measured in radians is numerically equal to the signed arc length on the unit circle.
Consequently, our original expression can be interpreted geometrically as the horizontal projection divided by the signed arc length.
As the point approaches the rightmost point of the circle:
- The horizontal projection approaches 1.
- The signed arc length approaches zero.
- The arc length is positive when approaching from above.
- The arc length is negative when approaching from below.
This provides another way to understand why the quotient becomes unbounded with opposite signs.
The use of radians is essential for this particular arc-length interpretation.
- Final summary
Let’s collect the important observations.
cos x approaches 1: the horizontal projection approaches the radius of the unit circle.
x approaches zero: the signed angle and signed arc length approach zero.
Right-hand quotient is positive: both numerator and denominator are positive.
Left-hand quotient is negative: the numerator is positive, but the denominator is negative.
Two-sided limit does not exist: the two one-sided limits have opposite infinite behaviour.
The final result is:
Therefore, the two-sided limit of cos x / x as x to tends to 0 does not exist.
Conclusion: Understanding Limits Through Geometry
This example demonstrates why understanding limits requires more than simply substituting values into an expression.
The unit circle reveals something that might not be immediately obvious from the algebraic expression.
As the angle approaches zero from either direction, the horizontal coordinate approaches the same positive value, 1.
However, the signed angle changes from positive to negative when crossing the horizontal axis.
This difference determines the behaviour of the quotient.
The key lesson is that a function can approach the same numerator value from both directions while its quotient behaves completely differently because of a sign change in the denominator.
Understanding this geometrically makes it easier to appreciate why we must examine left-hand and right-hand limits separately rather than assuming that both directions produce the same result.





Leave a Reply